Mollie Bean stayed at one of the rooms above the Liberty Saloon when she came to Nashville to meet Nate Caudell. On January 18, 1868, Bean led Caudell up to her room to show him the copy of The American Heritage Picture History of the Civil War she'd obtained. Tisdale was behind the bar when the two went up to Bean's room. As it was Sunday, the bar was empty. When Tisdale saw the two headed up, he raised his eyebrows but said nothing. Caudell was embarrassed anyway.[2]