User blog comment:JCC the Alternate Historian/Republican Vice Presidential candidates in Joe Steele (Guesses and Speculation)/@comment-25626-20180612152719

Not Nixon. We know exactly where he was.

McNary and Bricker make a lot of sense for 1940 and 1944, mainly because Knox was tapped in 1936 and Steele's presidency doesn't somehow make either inelligible or otherwise implausible. After that, pick two guys you find plausible.