Forum:Southern Victory Warships

User:Wikimage recently edited USS Missoula and USS Idaho to add OTL information on those US warships and the Southern Victory info as a sub-article. Normally we do this especially for historical persons and places but I am wondering whether its appropriate for these ships. Since they date from the Great War, they might close enough to the POD to be similar enough to the historical vessels for such treatment. However, we do have e.g Yorktown a disambiguation for a historical fleet carrier mentioned in several stories and treated as such and the escort carrier from Southern Victory which is treated as entirely fictional the way the USS Punishment was.

So do we treat all Southern Victory ships as fictional or do we use the historical information along with the SV particulars for those that are similar e.g. battleships such as the Missoula and Idaho? ML4E (talk) 21:10, January 2, 2014 (UTC)